The AFLUA aims to recognise and celebrate the achievements of its members and has introduced several initiatives to that end. One such initiative was the establishment of Grand Final Legends.
The AFLUA Executive Committee has decided not to elect umpires to Grand Final Legend status since 2013.
| Year | Field | Boundary | Goal |
| 2002 | Jack McMurray (Snr) Jack McMurray (Jnr) | ||
| 2005 | Jeff Crouch | Lindsay Lancaster | Harold Stevens OAM |
| 2006 | Allan Nash | Bill Quinn | Les Robinson |
| 2007 | Ian Robinson | John Fitt | Ernest Jenkins |
| 2008 | Henry Crapp | Kevin Mitchell | Reg Treloar |
| 2009 | Jack Elder | Norman Batty | Kevin Barker |
| 2010 | Eric Hawkins | Geoff Willcox | Les Barratt |
| 2011 | Arthur Norden | Leigh Paterson | Clyde White |
| 2012 | Brett Allen | Peter McDonald | William Wetenhall |
| 2013 | Robert Scott | Gordon Muir | Anthony Black |